Standard Hand-Decorated Cookies
$75
starting price per dozen
Approximately 3.5–4 inches
1-dozen minimum
Orders start at $75
Custom Hand-Decorated Sugar Cookies
Made for Life's Special Celebrations
From baby showers and birthdays to weddings and milestone celebrations, Tabitha's Cookie Jar creates custom hand-decorated sugar cookies designed around your special occasion.
Each cookie is made from scratch and decorated by hand, bringing your colors, theme, and ideas together in a personalized cookie set.
Our signature vanilla sugar cookies are thick, soft, and chewy, finished with lemon-flavored royal icing that balances the sweetness.
Cookies for Every Celebration
Your Occasion. Your Theme. My Creative Touch.
We create custom cookie sets for:
- Baby showers and gender reveals
- Bridal showers and weddings
- Birthdays and milestone celebrations
- Bachelorette parties
- Graduations and school celebrations
- Baptisms and religious celebrations
- Anniversaries and retirement parties
- Holidays and seasonal celebrations
Whether you have a specific design in mind or need help bringing your ideas together, we'd love to hear what you're planning.
Baby showers 
Bridal showers 
Weddings 
Kids' birthdays 
Milestone birthdays 
Graduations 
Baptisms 
Thank-you gifts
Custom Cookie Pricing
Hand-Decorated Sugar Cookies
Mini Hand-Decorated Cookies
$36
starting price per dozen
Approximately 2.5 inches
2-dozen minimum
Orders start at $72
Final pricing depends on the size, complexity, and details of your designs.
Prices do not include sales tax. Any sales tax that applies will be shown on your quote.
How Custom Ordering Works
A Simple, Personal Process
Step 1: Tell Me About Your Celebration
Complete the custom cookie inquiry form with your event date, quantity, theme, and colors.
Step 2: Share Your Inspiration
Upload invitations, photographs, or cookie designs that inspire you.
Step 3: I'll Review Your Request
I'll confirm availability and provide pricing based on your design ideas.
Step 4: Reserve Your Date
Payment in full is required to confirm your order and reserve your spot on my calendar. Your quote will include a link to my order terms so you can read them before you pay.
Step 5: I'll Create Your Cookies
Your cookies will be baked from scratch and individually decorated by hand.
Step 6: Pick Up Your Order
Custom cookie orders are available for pickup in Erie, Colorado, typically on Fridays between 2:00 and 4:00 p.m. Alternative pickup dates and times may be accommodated by prior arrangement.
A Note About Custom Designs
Inspiration Meets Creativity
I love seeing your inspiration photos, invitations, and ideas!
While I'm happy to incorporate specific designs you love, each cookie set is my interpretation of your theme. By placing an order, you're allowing me creative freedom to bring your ideas together.
Design mockups are available upon request.
Please keep in mind that colors may appear differently on screens and monitors. While I'll do my best to match your requested colors, exact color matching cannot be guaranteed.
Ordering & Availability
A Little Planning Goes a Long Way
Because each custom cookie set is decorated by hand, I accept a limited number of orders.
I recommend reaching out 4 weeks before your event.
Need cookies sooner? You're always welcome to ask! Shorter-notice orders may be available depending on my schedule.
Payment in full is required when booking.
Cookies With a Purpose
Your Celebration Makes a Difference
When you order from Tabitha's Cookie Jar, you're helping make a difference beyond your own celebration.
50% of every sale helps support children at an orphanage and school in Uganda.
Spreading love around the world... one sugar cookie at a time.
Let's Celebrate!
Have a special occasion coming up?
Tell me about your theme, colors, and ideas, and I'll let you know if I have availability.
Submit a Custom Cookie Inquiry
Please allow 1 to 2 business days for a response.